How loud should a song be for Spotify? We measured two masters of one song
At its Normal setting Spotify plays music at −14 LUFS, so a louder master is turned down, not played louder. We measured two masters of our own song, at −13.2 and −9.7 LUFS, to show what the extra loudness costs and how to check yours.
With loudness normalization on, Spotify turns every track toward the same loudness: −14 LUFS at its Normal setting. A master made louder than that doesn’t play louder. It is turned down. We measured two masters of one of our own songs with our free LUFS meter to show what the extra loudness costs.
Two masters of one song
“Asymptote” is a dance track we made in Instant DJ, our music app. We exported it twice: a first master, and a louder club master. Here are both, measured.
| First master | Club master | |
|---|---|---|
| Integrated loudness | −13.2 LUFS | −9.7 LUFS |
| True peak | −0.5 dBTP | −0.7 dBTP |
| Loudness range | 8.1 LU | 4.2 LU |
| Spotify at Normal (−14 LUFS) | down 0.8 dB | down 4.3 dB |
Loudness and true peak are as the LUFS meter shows them. Loudness range isn’t in the meter, so we measured it with ffmpeg’s EBU R 128 filter, which follows EBU Tech 3342: it is the spread of a song’s loudness over 3-second windows, leaving out the quietest 10% and the loudest 5% of them.
What Spotify does to each
Spotify’s help page for artists gives three playback levels: Normal (−14 LUFS), plus Loud (−11) and Quiet (−19), which Premium listeners can switch to. A louder master is turned down, which Spotify notes adds no distortion. A quieter one is turned up only until its true peak reaches −1 dB, leaving 1 dB of headroom for lossy encoding, except at Loud, where Spotify sets the level regardless of peaks and uses a limiter.
| Spotify setting | First master | Club master |
|---|---|---|
| Loud (−11 LUFS) | up 2.2 dB, with Spotify’s limiter | down 1.3 dB |
| Normal (−14 LUFS) | down 0.8 dB | down 4.3 dB |
| Quiet (−19 LUFS) | down 5.8 dB | down 9.3 dB |
Whichever level is in use, both masters play at about the same loudness: the club master’s extra 3.5 LU is taken away. Spotify’s web player and third-party devices such as TVs and speakers don’t normalize, and there the club master does play louder.
What the extra loudness costs
Turned down to the same loudness, the two masters still differ. The club master is 3.5 LU louder with almost the same peak level, so the extra loudness came from squeezing the music’s dynamics. Two numbers show it:
- Loudness range: 8.1 LU against 4.2 LU. The club master’s quieter and louder passages are about half as far apart.
- Peaks above the average: 12.7 dB against 9.0 dB. That’s true peak minus integrated loudness. Played at −14 LUFS, the first master’s highest peak reaches −1.3 dBTP and the club master’s −5.0 dBTP, 3.7 dB lower. Squeezing a master louder works mostly by holding down short peaks like these: the attack of drums and other hits.
On Spotify, then, the louder master gains nothing in level, and gives up contrast between its passages and the height of its peaks.
The peak advice
Spotify also suggests keeping the true peak below −1 dBTP, and below −2 dBTP for a master louder than −14 LUFS, because louder tracks are more likely to distort when they’re encoded for streaming.
Both of our masters are louder than −14 LUFS and peak above −2 dBTP, so for a Spotify release we would lower the master’s ceiling to −2 dB and export again. They’re also M4A files, which have already been through one lossy encode. For a release, send your distributor a WAV, so the only lossy encode is Spotify’s own.
Check your own master
Drop the file into the LUFS meter. It measures integrated loudness, true peak and sample peak in your browser, without uploading the file, then tells you what Spotify will do to it, whether its true peak is within Spotify’s advice, and how it compares with the levels Apple Podcasts and EBU R 128 ask for. Measure the file you will actually deliver.
In Instant DJ
The Studio in Instant DJ (in the iPad app now, and on the Mac from version 1.6) has a master with a loudness target and a Ceiling knob, “the highest the limiter lets a peak go”. The target menu marks −14 LUFS as streaming and −9 as club, and the ceiling starts at −1 dB. For Spotify, pick −14 and keep the ceiling at −1 dB, or turn it down to −2 dB if you want the master louder than −14. Press “Set the gain for the target”, export a WAV, and check its true peak in the meter before you upload it.
Questions, answered
- How loud should a song be for Spotify?
- Spotify's own advice is to master to −14 LUFS integrated, with the true peak below −1 dBTP, or below −2 dBTP if the master is louder than −14 LUFS. At its Normal setting Spotify plays tracks at −14 LUFS, so a louder master is turned down rather than played louder.
- Does Spotify turn down loud songs?
- Yes, with normalization on: a track louder than the playback level is turned down to it. That level is −14 LUFS at Normal; Premium listeners can also choose Loud (−11) or Quiet (−19). Spotify's web player and third-party devices such as TVs and speakers don't normalize.
- Does Spotify turn up quiet songs?
- Only until its true peak reaches −1 dB: Spotify leaves 1 dB of headroom for lossy encoding. Its example is a −20 LUFS track with a true peak of −5 dBFS, which is raised to −16 LUFS, not −14. At the Loud setting it sets the level regardless of peaks and uses a limiter.
- What is true peak?
- The highest level of the waveform, including between the samples a file stores. A peak can fall between two samples, so true peak can read above the highest sample; it is measured by upsampling, as ITU-R BS.1770 describes, and written in dBTP. Encoding to MP3, AAC or Ogg can push peaks higher again, which is why streaming services ask for headroom.